AccScience Publishing / AC / Volume 2 / Issue 3 / DOI: 10.36922/ac.2642
ARTICLE

Painter Leonardo da Vinci or Leonardo from Caffa in Crimea: Challenging the attribution of selected documents

Susan A. Grundy1*
Show Less
1 Independent Researcher, Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom
Submitted: 5 January 2024 | Accepted: 6 March 2024 | Published: 17 July 2024
© 2024 by the Author(s). This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution -Noncommercial 4.0 International License (CC-by the license) ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ )
Abstract

This article reinterprets four documents attributed to the artist Leonardo da Vinci. These documents include a drawing considered to be a Tuscan landscape with an inscribed date of August 5, 1473, a single double-sided page with drawings, writings, and a tensioning crossbow design dated 1478, a drawing of a hanged man dated 1479, and a letter written in Turkish to the Sultan of Istanbul dated circa 1502. If the Tuscan painter created these documents, he was pursuing an alternative career as a scientist. However, the information is incomplete and inaccurate. First, the landscape does not represent Tuscany. Instead, further research indicates that it is the depiction of a fortress in Crimea that relates to significant events occurring in the Ottoman arena between 1473 and 1475. Second, biographers have failed to show evidence that the Tuscan painter had military connections, raising the issue of a non-affiliation with any militia. Third, the sketch of a hanged man focuses an unexplained attention on the victim’s Turkish style of dress. Finally, a letter sent to Istanbul around 1502 claimed Leonardo was Genoese. Taking note of these points, a cumulative reading of the evidence shows that the man who crafted these documents originated from Caffa, a Genoese colony on the Black Sea that the Ottomans captured in 1475. Although this might sound speculative, further documents discussed in the final section indicate that Florence banished the Tuscan painter Leonardo da Vinci around 1477 and that he later died in Bologna in 1499. Therefore, this Tuscan Leonardo could not have written the Notebooks, and the man who died in France in 1519 could not have been him. The research adds a deeper understanding of Turkish influences in the documents and highlights how information gathered outside Europe can better explain them. The findings urge Western art historians to expand their research and to reconsider other authors.

Keywords
Italian Renaissance
Leonardo da Vinci
Landscape drawing 1473
Leonardo Eastern slave mother theory
Caffa
Ottoman Empire
The Notebooks
Horizontal art history
Funding
None.
Conflict of interest
The author declares no conflicts of interest.
References
  1. Jakubowska A, Radomska M, editors. Horizontal Art History and Beyond: Revisiting Peripheral Crucial Practices. Oxford: Rutledge; 2023. p. 3.

 

  1. Richter JP. The Complete Notebooks of Leonardo da Vinci. Vol. 2. (1888). London: Dover Publications; 2016. p. 285.

 

  1. Paratico A. Leonardo da Vinci: A Chinese Scholar Lost in Renaissance Italy. Hong Kong: Lascar Publishing; 2015.

 

  1. Vecce C. Il Sorriso di Caterina: La Madre di Leonardo. Florence: Giunti; 2023. p. 46-47.

 

  1. Doğan H. Hidden Secrets in Mona Lisa: Islamic Codes of Da Vinci. Seattle: Amazon Kindle and Prime; 2017.

 

  1. Vezzosi A, Sabato A. The new genealogical tree of the Da Vinci Family for Leonardo’s DNA. Ancestors and descendants in direct male line down to the present XXI generation. Hum Evol. 2021;36(1-2):1-90. doi: 10.14673/HE2021121077

 

  1. Origo I. The domestic enemy: The Eastern slaves in Tuscany in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. Speculum. 1955;30(3):326.

 

  1. Vasari G. In: Bondanella JC, Bondanella P, editors. The Lives of the Artists. Translated with an introduction and notes. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1991. p. 292.

 

  1. Frosinini C. Recto and verso, righwise and leftwise. Drawing 8P of the Ufizzi Gallery: In search of the meaning. In: Barsanti R, editor. Leonardo in Vinci. At the Origins of the Genius. Florence: Giunti; 2019. p. 246.

 

  1. Nicholl C. Leonardo da Vinci: The Flights of the Mind. London: Penguin Books; 2005. p. 49.

 

  1. Delorme A. Leonardo da Vinci’s First Drawing, Landscape of the Arno Valley (1473), a Reflection on the Allegorical Painting of Dante Alighieri’s Divine Comedy by Domenico di Michelino (1465). Academia.edu; 2022.

 

  1. Somel SA. The A to Z of the Ottoman Empire. Lanham, Maryland: Scarecrow Press; 2010. p. 35.

 

  1. Imber C. The Ottoman Empire 1300-1481. Istanbul: The Isis Press; 1990. p. 225-228.

 

  1. Frazee CA. Catholics and Sultans: The Church and the Ottoman Empire 1453-1923. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 2006. p. 16.

 

  1. Kemp M. Leonardo da Vinci: The 100 Milestones. New York: Sterling; 2019. p. 5.

 

  1. Grundy SA. More Than (2) Leonardo in Anti-Theory: Mothers, Slaves, Imposters, Codes, Cross-dressers, and Collaborators. Google Play; 2023. p. 23, 89-91.

 

  1. Available from: https://en-gb.topographic-map.com/map-bsjgp/crimean-peninsula [Last accessed on 2024 Jul 15].

 

  1. Grinevetsky SR, Zonn IS, Zhiltsov SS, Korsarev AN, Kostianoy AG. The Black Sea Encyclopedia. Berlin: Springer; 2014. p. 295.

 

  1. Available from: https://guidetocrimea.ru/sudak-genoese-fortress [Last accessed on 2024 Feb 17].

 

  1. Villata E. 1478, a Year in Leonardo da Vincis Career. Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars; 2021. p. 22.

 

  1. Villata E. 1478, a Year in Leonardo da Vincis Career. Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars; 2021. p. 7-8.

 

  1. Caferro W. The Florentine army in the age of the companies of adventure. Millar Esp Hist. 2017;25:129-150. doi: 10.6035/Millars.2017.43.5

 

  1. Grundy SA. More Than (2) Leonardo in Anti-Theory: Mothers, Slaves, Imposters, Codes, Cross-dressers, and Collaborators. Google Play; 2023. p. 48.

 

  1. Villata E. 1478, a Year in Leonardo da Vincis Career. Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars; 2021. p. 1-10.

 

  1. Landrus M. Leonardo da Vinci’s Giant Crossbow. Berlin: Springer; 2010. p. 53.

 

  1. Esposito G. Renaissance Armies in Italy 1450-1550. London: Bloomsbury; 2020. p. 20.

 

  1. Iordanou I. Venices Secret Service: Organising Intelligence in the Renaissance. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2019. p. 86.

 

  1. Nicholl C. Leonardo da Vinci: The Flights of the Mind. New York: Penguin Books; 2005. p. 140.

 

  1. Atalay B, Wamsley K. Leonardo’s Universe: The Renaissance World of Leonardo da Vinci. Washington, DC: National Geographic Books; 2008. p. 32.

 

  1. Grundy SA. Leonardo da Vinci: The power of interpretation. S Afr J Art Hist. 2020;35(1):210-220.

 

  1. Chugtai Museum Blog. Available from: http://blog. chughtaimuseum.com/?p=11882 [Last accessed on 2023 Dec 19].

 

  1. Payne R. Leonardo. New York: Doubleday; 1978. p. 175.

 

  1. Nicholl C. Leonardo da Vinci: The Flights of the Mind. New York: Penguin Books; 2005. p. 353.

 

  1. Grundy SA. Leonardo: The Making and Breaking of a European Myth. United States: Lulu Direct Publishing; 2023. p. 86-87.

 

  1. Pedretti, C. Paulo di Leonardo. Achademia Leonardi Vinci. Journal of Leonardo Studies and Bibliography of Vinciana. 1992; V: 120–22.

 

  1. Nicholl C. Leonardo Da Vinci: The Flights of the Mind. New York: Penguin Books; 2005. p. 248.

 

  1. Villata E. 1478, a Year in Leonardo da Vincis Career. Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars; 2021. p. 15.
Share
Back to top
Arts & Communication, Electronic ISSN: 2972-4090 Published by AccScience Publishing